Towards A 21st Century Retirement System

Posted on October 15, 2010

Poll after poll suggests that working Americans are deeply concerned about their future retirement income, and a recent analysis conducted by the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College suggests that those fears are well founded. The retirement income deficit–the difference between what Americans (ages 32-64) have set aside for retirement and what they should have set aside at this time in their lives—is a staggering $6.6 trillion. On average, that works out to a retirement deficit of about $90,000 per American household.

The flip side of the retirement income deficit is that retirement savings has not been generating the kind of aggregate national savings that we need to finance capital expansion and economic growth. For the moment, that’s not a problem: economists are more concerned about expanding spending than savings. But in the long term, countries need high rates of saving to maintain prosperity, and the U.S. is no exception.

Meanwhile, our current patchwork system of retirement plans is falling apart at the seams. Pension coverage has been declining for decades and the “do-it-yourself” approach embodied in many 401(k) plans is a demonstrated failure. Too many workers are withdrawing money from their already depressed 401(k) balances to cover the cost of college education and other household needs, while high administrative costs and poor investment decisions are eroding the returns of those have tried diligently to save for retirement.

So where do we begin in designing a 21^st century retirement system for American workers? We should start with three overarching goals–universal coverage, adequacy, and security—and recognize that we have a long ways to go.

Presently, only about half of the private workforce is enrolled in an employer-sponsored retirement plan, and only one out of five have a traditional pension.

Even before the Great Recession, it was evident that our excessive reliance on individual retirement accounts was not working. In 2007, just half of all families had an IRA or a 401(k)-type retirement plan and the median level of savings was just $45,000. It’s no wonder that half of American households are headed towards an inadequately funded retirement.

Other countries, however, have faced similar challenges. In Australia a national “superannuation” program was introduced in 1992 by the Labor government. Employers were required to contribute 3 percent of payroll. At the outset, the plan was strongly opposed by small businesses, but ten years later, employers were contributing 9 percent, and the program was a widely applauded success. By 2006 Australian workers had more money invested in managed funds per capita than workers in any other country. The impact on the economy? Between 1994 and 2004, Australia’s per capita GDP increased by an impressive 2.5 percent a year, significantly faster than 1.7 percent pace recorded between 1984 and 1994.

In the Netherlands, employers have developed a popular new “collective defined contribution plan,” a hybrid of the traditional pension plan and defined contribution plans. Designed to minimize the risks borne by businesses, the employer has a fixed contribution and no additional obligations if the plan should be come underfunded. Employees receive an annual notice outlining what benefits they have accrued and what benefits they will receive if they continue working to age 65.

Neither of these approaches is perfect. The Australian superannuation system does not pay an annuitized benefit; it pays a lump sum. As a result, some retirees outlive their benefits. The Netherlands approach, on the other hand, does not guarantee benefits; when the stock market declines, benefits can be reduced. Both, however, have boosted national savings and increased retirement security. Both countries opted for a better approach to retirement security, and so should we.

In designing a system for the United States, we should begin by recognizing the need for shared responsibility. Employers, employees and government should all have a role. Retirement USA, a coalition of organizations representing workers and retirees, has rallied around that approach. The group argues, and rightly so, that employers and employees should both contribute, and that government should subsidize the contributions of lower-income workers. They propose that contributions be pooled and professionally managed to ensure greater adequacy and security for the workers who need it most. They also recommend that benefits should be portable and the whole system professionally managed. These are principles worth building upon.

More than anything, what we need today is bold thinking. Seventy-five years ago, in the midst of the Great Depression, we created a Social Security system that has evolved into the most successful anti-poverty program ever devised. Today, we have an opportunity to create a whole new approach to retirement security, one that will serve the interests of both workers and the economy. The polls suggest that voters are eager and ready for such a new direction; what’s lacking is the political vision and leadership.

This blog entry was written by Robert Walker who formerly served as Legislative Counsel for AARP and presently is a consultant to the Pension Rights Center. This blog entry is cross-posted on CenteredPolitics.com.

Tags: 401(k) plans, Retirement Income Deficit, retirement security, Retirement USA

Comments

I studied this article then I

Submitted by Anonymous on Fri, 2013-05-17 04:10.

I studied this article then I found here more information about system like retirement. Yes, It is thoughtful point in employee lives. we should think about it deeply and take any meaningful decision. thesports-bettingg

Nike Air Jordan Air

Submitted by Anonymous on Sat, 2013-05-04 04:32.

Nike Air Jordan Air Jordans Nike Air Jordan Retro Jordan Shoes Nike Air Jordan Shoes Air Jordan 1 Air Jordan 2011 Air Jordan 2012 Air Jordan 2013 Air Jordan Retro Air Jordan Aero Air Jordan Cp3 Air Jordan Flight Air Jordan Fly Air Jordan Melo Air Jordan Play Air Jordan Rcvr Air Max 360 Jordan Air Jordan Son Of Mars

マイケルコーススモールバッグ

Submitted by Anonymous on Thu, 2013-05-02 10:27.

にチェックすることによって、このようなナイキフリー2、ナイキフリー3、ナイキフリー4.0V2およびもっとたくさんのようにナイキフリーランニングシューズの最新モデルを見つけるでしょう。サイチャンルートは、ナイキフリー3メンズとナイキフリー3レディースの最新の色やスタイルを提供しています。したがって、あなただけのすべてが、サイト上にあるためのあなたの好みのナイキフリーを買いにモールや履物店に行く必要はありません。ウェブサイト上のメンバーであることによって、あなたが頻繁にれんがとモルタル履物店に存在しないすべての購入に大きな割引を楽しむことができます。サイトからナイキフリーランニングシューズの多くを購入し、より多くの貯蓄を稼ぐ機会をつかむ。それはあなたの目の前に到達するまで、最高の信頼できる宅配サービスと提携し、同社は損傷からあなたの項目が自由に処理するため、配送は問題ではありません。返品の場合は、あなたがする必要があるすべての返品に関するページを読むことです。あなたにpunchfrees.coアディダススニーカーランニング mについての簡単な歴史を与えるために、同社は2008年に運用を開始しました。それはそのようなエアマックス、ルナとナイキフリーとしてナイキランニングシューズの販売を開始。消費者からの強い要望があったので、会社は彼らの製品ラインを拡大し、顧客に多くの品種ナイキランニングシューズを提供しています。これは、同社の顧客が幸せと満足させておくことです。すべてのあなたのランニングシューズのニーズに、信頼する唯一の店があります。によってこれまでの間、最もトレンディなゴルフクラブのモデルが最新の振り回す伴うお金をやった。あなたがこれまでに治療Webベースで探して起動した場モンスタービート合年低コストのナイキ環境履物のget。彼らはただ、非常に利便性のために有名で、さらにスタイルと相まって切望とdesign.Nikeはスポーツzapatillasナイキ無料靴からあなたのホットなメーカーに属している。彼らは、特定の必需品のために意味なされているスポーツウェアやサンダルの良い品揃えを持っている。一つは、常にあなたのすべての機能のための適切な監督を取得する必要があります。あなたが適切なスニーマイケルコーススモールバッグカーを提示していトリーバーチサンダルない場合、それは一般的に、12インチと良いつま先共有傷害をもたらすことができ、膝と同様にhips.Weは、熟練と高い位置のブランド製品の商社ですし、また数多くのスキンの名物になるだろうとナイキ同様にナイキエアジョーダンなどショックス、および多くの他と組み合わせる高品質ナイキエアナマケモノ履物。

cyclingjerseyset

Submitted by Anonymous on Sat, 2013-04-27 23:16.

Cycling Jersey, Cycling jersey Shop the largest selection of Primal Cycling Jerseys.Find a great selection of Cycling Jerseys deals on eBay!Cycling apparel that encourages athletes to progress not only in sport but in life.Custom Cycling Jerseys, Skinsuits, and Shorts.Bike Wear, bike wear Find great deals on eBay for World Champion Cycling Jersey in Men's Cycling Clothing. Shop with confidence.Offering a huge selection of cycling jerseys, bicycle shorts at sale prices. Primal Wear, Falconi, bibshorts, cycling shorts, bicycle jerseys, team cycling jerseys.Bike Jersey, bike jersey, Cycling Jerseys that make a statement. Buy a Cycling Jersey and tell drivers to share the damn road.Using a vast array of patented material technology, Assos has created the pinnacle of lightweight ergonomic cycling jerseys.Bike Clothing, bike clothing, Designed to be loose and much less confining while on or off the bike with all the technical aspects you're looking for in a high quality jersey.A creative cycling jersey is your best shot at establishing a unique identity on the bike. But where do you find one that's both comfortable and unforgettable?Cycling Shorts, Cycling Shorts, This Pro level Cycling Jersey is named after the Bianchi top performing racing bike, the Bianchi Oltre.Arrogant Bastard Jerseys ship fast with free shipping.Cycling Clothing Cycling clothing Breathable tights that have wind-resistant fronts are best. If the tights you select don't have padded bottoms (they often don't), wear them over your bike shorts. http://www.procyclingjersey.net/ http://www.cyclingjerseyset.com/

cheap wholesale from china

Submitted by Anonymous on Mon, 2013-04-22 09:25.

Much like every other product in the max assortment, men nike air max 2013 are manufactured to include more cushioning, The nike air max 2013 mens uses a large air cushioning unit at the heel which is visible from the side of the midsole in most models. No release date has been set yet, but stay tuned to china wholesale shoes as more information becomes available. This message by cheap nike shox free shipping written. Sale men nike air max light are designed for handsome and cool; Mens nike air max store provide different kinds of max shoes for cheap. Buy real china shoes sale at our online china nike shoes online shop. This message by cheap nike shoes free shipping written. The mens air jordan 14 retro is a design which has a timeless look and the pair is practical. We offer cheap air jordan 14 retro online sale and fast shipping all around the world, The air jordan usa to great demand, including a new colorway featuring Michael Jordan's high school colors. This message by nike shoes sale written. Wearing the St.Louis Rams Elite Jerseys of their favorite team or favorite players is important to support and cheer their team. The nike nfl elite jerseys are the retail version of the on-field jersey the Team wears. if you are interested in our china jerseys sale. This message by cheap nfl jerseys free shipping written. Worldwide wholesale hermes handbags, amazing discount price replica hermes handbag, When you look around our store, you will find all kinds of fashionable replica hermes handbags. It is not just a bag, but also the the symbol of our status and they tells the planet you have a good knockoff handbags sale of fashion. This message by wholesale cheap replica handbags written. You can find a wide variety of women nike free 4.0 v2 for some of the lowest prices here. Dare to run free with the nike free running shoe. The usa nike shoes online upper construction provides light support role, can experience such as skin-like fit in every step. This message by usa nike shoes sale written.

movers alexandria va

Submitted by Anonymous on Thu, 2013-04-18 12:34.

Hey great stuff, thank you for sharing this useful information and i will let know my friends as well. movers alexandria va

Coffee bean extract

Submitted by Anonymous on Thu, 2013-04-18 12:30.

This is a really good read for me, Must admit that you are one of the best bloggers I ever saw. Thanks for posting this informative Information.Coffee bean extract

dc locksmith

Submitted by Anonymous on Thu, 2013-04-18 10:35.

Really good website this is, full of useful information and advice. Thanks for sharing.dc locksmith

moving companies washington dc

Submitted by Anonymous on Thu, 2013-04-18 06:35.

Great Information, very interesting and useful for me. Thanks!moving companies washington dc

change locks west chester

Submitted by Anonymous on Thu, 2013-04-18 06:28.

I am so glad this internet thing works and your Information really helped me. Might take you up on that home advice you. change locks west chester

movers dc

Submitted by Anonymous on Thu, 2013-04-18 04:12.

Good info and Thanks for sharing this with us.movers dc

joli

Submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 2013-04-17 07:41.

Awesome post, thanks so much for sharing this with us! locksmith in west chester

joli

Submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 2013-04-17 06:33.

Good info and Thanks for sharing this with us. 24 hour locksmith queens

joli

Submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 2013-04-17 05:24.

I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this post. wholesale health products

joli

Submitted by Anonymous on Tue, 2013-04-16 11:29.

It is my pleasure that I have the unique opportunity to comment on this awesome post. change a lock

joli

Submitted by Anonymous on Tue, 2013-04-16 09:25.

Thanks for providing such useful information. I really appreciate your professional approach. supper foods

best vitamins for hair loss

Submitted by Anonymous on Tue, 2013-04-16 07:28.

Thanks for sharing it. I found this Information very interesting and informative! Keep sharing!best vitamins for hair loss

buy best supplements

Submitted by Anonymous on Tue, 2013-04-16 07:18.

Thanks for posting this. i really enjoyed reading this. buy best supplements

buy natural supplements

Submitted by Anonymous on Tue, 2013-04-16 07:01.

It is my pleasure that I have the unique opportunity to comment on this awesome post. buy natural supplements

joli

Submitted by Anonymous on Tue, 2013-04-16 06:14.

I am so happy to read this. This is the kind of manual that needs to be given and not the random misinformation that's at the other blogs. Thanks for sharing this.
woodbridge locksmith

locksmith va

Submitted by Anonymous on Tue, 2013-04-16 05:25.

I was always in search of such useful information you have shared in this blog. This will help me in my working.locksmith va

maryland movers

Submitted by Anonymous on Mon, 2013-04-15 10:52.

Thanks for providing such useful information. I really appreciate your professional approach.maryland movers

best herbal supplements

Submitted by Anonymous on Fri, 2013-04-12 10:55.

Great Information, very interesting and useful for me. Thanks! best herbal supplements

kallas

Submitted by Anonymous on Fri, 2013-04-12 05:55.

I am really enjoying reading your well written Information. I think you spend numerous effort and time updating your blog. I have bookmarked it and I am taking a look ahead to reading new Information. Please keep up the good Information! 24 hour locksmith brooklyn

locksmith in va

Submitted by Anonymous on Thu, 2013-04-11 11:38.

I am very happy to get this post and comment here. locksmith in va

kallas

Submitted by Anonymous on Thu, 2013-04-11 10:33.

This is a really good read for me, Must admit that you are one of the best bloggers I ever saw. Thanks for posting this informative Information.best moving company ................................................................................................................................. This is a really informative knowledge, Thanks for posting this informative Information.locksmith dc

bethesda locksmith

Submitted by Anonymous on Thu, 2013-04-11 10:22.

I am very happy to get this post and comment here. bethesda locksmith

kallas

Submitted by Anonymous on Thu, 2013-04-11 07:24.

Very interesting thanks. I believe there's even more that could be on there! Keep it up. arlington locksmith

サッカーユニフォームクラブチームグッズ

Submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 2013-04-10 10:10.

そのような洗浄方法として一般的なカーペットクリーニングのために物事はあなたが持っているカーペットの形に基づいています。だからカーペットや繊維の種類が異なる洗浄方法は、洗い流す必要 ADIDASアディダス CAMPUS があります。あなたはウールのカーペットまたは繊維を持っているなら、ドライクリーニングは汚??れを自由にするための最良の方法です。すべての合併症や頭痛を克服するために、ちょうどあなたのカーペットを洗浄するためのサービスを洗浄バーンズクリーンチームのカーペットを使用して、お気に入りのホームカーペットとの長期的な関係を作る。私たちのサービスを雇うためにはここに私たちを見つナイキジョーダン2 けてください：手ごろな価格のクリーニングサービスをあなたは毎日オフィスの清掃、毎週または毎月のサービス、または単に1回だけの用務のサービスを必要とするかどうか、あなたは一流のオフィスのために良好なクリーニングサービスを頼りにすることができ、今日利用可能な無敵の料金でクリーニング。いくつかはまた、責任および物的損害の範囲だけでなく、従業員のボンディングおよび保険の他のすべての適用可能なフォームを提供する。だから行くと最も良いものを選ぶ。あなたは最高のレキシントンのカーペットクリーナーを見つけるために行にジャンプアップすることができますまたはオフラインでも専門的なアドバイスを受けることができます。多くのクリーニングサービスファインダがあります。商業および国内の両方に優れたカーペット、ラグマット、および家具製造販売業のクサッカーユニフォームクラブチームグッズリーニングサービス、タイル、堅木の床のクリーニングサービスと同様に、水の損傷の修理を提供し多くの人々があります。レキシントンのカーペットのクリーニングは汚??れの除去、汚れ、アレルゲンのために行われ、カーペット等の美化のためにそれは基本的にスチームクリーニング、ドライカーペットクリーニングおよび多くのような五つの基本的な専門家によるクリーニング方法論を受け入れています。いくつかのためにクリーニングカーペットは、あなたの要件に合うように市場から最高のカーペットクリーナーを選択する必要があるとして、本当の大きな問題です。ここに汚れ、汚れ＆破片の抽出が深く行われます。ドライケミカルシステムを用いたボンネットや炭酸化の方法のような多くの洗浄方法は、カーペットヤーンからするために使用されています。この方法は、あなたのカーペットやラアディダスオリジナルスグをスムーズにし、長期利用facility.Kobeブライアントのシグネチャースニーカーラインはいくつかの非常に印象的なバスケットボールシューズを生産して提供するために役に立ちます。これは、すべて神戸IVを始めています。それはバスケットボールのコミュニティの間で最も人気のある靴ローカットシューズを作った靴だった。この靴は、業界最高の性能基準で建てられただけでなく、それはバスケットボールシューズが今まで見た中で最も創造的のcolorwaysにリリースされました。その初期の神戸の靴が発売されたので、後に2つのエディションでは、高性能化とカラーデザインのためのバーを上げた。神戸の靴滴の最後の3年は、COP作成された最も想像を絶するスニーカーの一部へのスニーカーヘッズを許可している。まあ、人々は、それだけで良くなってきています。または、私が言うべきであり、より良い、より良い、より良い。神戸VIIは3つの異なるモデルにリリースする予定だからです。これは過去3年間見てきたように3倍の数のcolorwaysを意味します！まだ興奮して？